See my free book offer to readers at the end of this Contemplation…

Part I: The Rules of the Game (The Unbreakable Laws)
This section will lay out the foundational and non-negotiable physical and biological constraints on human activity. Constraints that our sociopolitical and economics models mostly ignore.
Chapter 1: The Only Game in Town: Thermodynamics and the Iron Law of Entropy
The House Always Wins
A casino sits in the desert. It has no name, sign, or doorman. It’s been operating for about thirteen billion years and no one has ever beaten the house. You can build order within it, but a price must be paid for doing so. You can create a star, planet, civilisation, or a thought but a bill will always be presented. The currency for paying such bills is entropy.

The first law of thermodynamics states that energy can neither be created nor destroyed, only changed from one form to another. The second law states that in any closed system entropy always increases via disorder, randomness, and/or a move to equilibrium. These two laws, without exception and without mercy, are immutable and the closest thing we have to universal truth about the universe. They are not hypotheses or theories subject to revision, politics, or magical thinking. These are the rules of the game for everything. All living beings. Every complex society. Planets. Galaxies. Everything.
These laws are the most concrete facts we have about existence. They are the reason we eat, breathe, reason, build, burn, bury, and why complex societies are possible at all. And they are the reason these societies will not and cannot last forever.
Archaeology shows us that virtually every complex society that has ever arisen has also fallen. This pattern is not accidental. It is the consequence of the laws of thermodynamics, the limits of ecology, and the finitude of resources. Our hopes, dreams, and plans for our future are of no concern to these laws. They simply are and they are telling us in no uncertain terms, with a voice that gets louder with each passing day, that our current global-spanning industrial society’s time is coming to its end.
The Inheritance
Forests, swamp, and shallow seas teeming with life covered our planet four hundred million years ago. The plants and plankton at that time did something remarkable: they captured and stored energy from sunlight. And for hundreds of millions of years they grew, died, sank into the mud, and got buried under layers of sediment and rock. These remains were transformed into various types of hydrocarbons through the pressure and heat of the Earth, creating pockets of ancient stored energy buried and preserved.
This has been humanity’s inheritance; a one-time trust fund from the deep past of energy that took hundreds of millions of years to accumulate. Yet, in the span of just a couple of centuries our species has spent the vast majority of this gift.
The numbers behind this gift are staggering. Roughly 1700 kilowatt-hours of energy are contained in a single barrel of oil, the equivalent of what a human labourer could produce in roughly four and a half years of continuous work. Our world currently consumes close to 100 million of such barrels per day, equivalent to 450 billion labourers working 24 hours a day, 365 days a year without rest or food. This is what powers Modernity and has made it possible. It’s not our intelligence, culture, institutions, or values. It’s our burning of our vast inheritance of concentrated energy that has allowed us to build our cities, industrial agriculture systems, modes of transportation, modern medicine, and everything else we take for granted. And it’s all been built on the assumption that we would never run out of this cheap energy and the power it provides.
But it is running out. Not in the sense that the oil spigots will simply stop working one day because there’s no oil left since a lot remains in the ground; however, the quality is declining, the cost of extraction is increasing, and the net energy available to support our complexities is shrinking. We have moved from the easy-to-retrieve and cheap-to-extract hydrocarbons to the hard-to-retrieve, expensive-to-extract, and more-ecologically-degrading hydrocarbons. As I stated earlier, the laws of thermodynamics don’t care about our economic models, political ideologies, or technological optimism. They tell us that we cannot get something for nothing and that each barrel extracted costs energy with the energy cost going up with each new barrel extracted.
This is an example of the central lesson of history that archaeologist Ronald Wright called a progress trap. Every solution creates new problems and in the case of complex societies, the very things that allow them to flourish are ultimately the things that lead to their simplification. In the case of our hydrocarbon inheritance, we solved certain issues with the industrial revolution, the agricultural revolution, and a globe-spanning economic system all predicated upon hydrocarbons. But these led us into ecological overshoot and the broaching of most of the planetary boundaries, including resource depletion, biodiversity loss, ocean acidification, and novel entities everywhere (think microplastics).
This is not a political statement. It is not a doomer fantasy. It is physics and the iron law of entropy.
The Balance Sheet
Here’s a synopsis that an economist might understand.
Every human action and activity is an energy transaction. You invest and extract energy in every activity. Food production, for example, requires sunlight, soil nutrients, human labour, and hydrocarbons to get the food calories out. Constructing a city of buildings, roadways, and infrastructure requires materials, labour, and transportation inputs. And to build an economic system (which is really an energy system) you require the conversion of low-entropy resources into high-entropy waste, capturing some of the difference as economic value.
The energy return on investment (EROI) has been low but positive for most of human history. Hunter-gatherers obtained roughly ten calories of food for every one they expended, while early farmers obtained roughly three–but this lower return per unit of labour was offset by a far higher yield per unit of land and greater reliability of food, which allowed humans to begin building larger, more complex societies with urban centres, specialised trades, art, writing, law, philosophy, military, and sociopolitical bureaucracies and elite. Civilisation is what can be accomplished with energy surplus.
Everything changed with hydrocarbons. For every calorie of energy put into extracting them, about 100 were available as surplus, depending on the methodology used and the era examined. This was a surplus unlike anything humans had experienced in their history; an absolutely unimaginable windfall. And boy did we spend it, like drunken sailors in port for the first time in months. Industrialisation and resource extraction. Highways and suburbs. Skyscrapers and shopping malls. Personal transportation and cruise ships. Space flight. Global supply chains. Military-industrial complexes. Data centres. A highly complex global, industrial civilisation, with the assumption the party would never end.
But ending it is. Hydrocarbon EROI has decreased from the 100:1 of the 1930s to today’s of about 10:1 (or less, depending on how you measure it). Deepwater drilling, tar sands refining, and hydraulic fracturing; these are the sources of most of our hydrocarbons nowadays, and they return far less energy than the conventional pockets of the twentieth century where oil “gushed from the ground”–much like that immortalised in the opening credits for the 1960s show The Beverly Hillbillies, where mountaineer Jed Clampett fired a rifle at some food and up from the ground came bubbling crude oil leading to his family’s sudden enrichment and subsequent move from the backwoods to Beverly Hills.
We continue to extract hydrocarbons and burn it to power our complex societies, we are simply getting increasingly less net surplus energy to support our complexities. The profit margin that we used to expand our industrialisation across the planet and reorganise our societies into Modernity is shrinking, and with this it is becoming more fragile.
Archaeologist Joseph Tainter discusses this pattern in his thesis on the collapse of societies. The problem solving we engage in to solve basic issues of survival results in increasing complexity, and we typically implement the least expensive and most effective solutions first. Later solutions to problems (most of which have been created by the initial solutions) tend to be more expensive and less effective. These diminishing returns on investments in complexity are really the diminishing returns on investments in energy–they are the same issue just seen from different perspectives. The message they are sending is that the bill for our problem solving is coming due.
The laws of thermodynamics tell us what this means for our complex societies and their expansion and maintenance: it cannot go on forever as there is a limit, and the costs must be paid. This is not a choice and cannot be paid by policy but by physics.
The Feather and the Hammer
This is where a number of people will raise the prospects of technological salvation. From energy-harvesting technologies (i.e., solar photovoltaic and wind turbines) to the nuclear renaissance will come the claims that these are growing exponentially with costs decreasing with each and every iteration and technical breakthrough.
I have heard these objections again and again, with ever greater force as our surplus gets smaller and smaller. And I understand their appeal as they support the narrative that we can keep our party going and expanding; that we cannot only keep Modernity but sustain it beyond the planet as well. The laws of thermodynamics, although patient, are non-negotiable.
I disagree most vehemently with the notion that a solution is offered through “renewables” and the massive and expedient buildout that many are calling for to “save us”. I realise that this position runs against the grain of most environmental thinking, but I’ve come to this conclusion somewhat reluctantly based upon the evidence surrounding them and offer it as a challenge to conventional thinking–this is not the “solution” you are looking for.
Renewables are not sources of energy as hydrocarbons are; they are energy-harvesting technologies that convert energy from one form to another. They are also mass-produced industrial technologies that require significant energy and material inputs that in turn require mining, refining, fabrication, transportation, installation, and ongoing maintenance. Almost all of the inputs depend upon hydrocarbons in one form or another, so they are not some gift from the sun and wind. They are a product of the hydrocarbon economy and cannot exist or be maintained without that economy.
On top of this issue is the fact that the growth of these technologies has done little to nothing to replace hydrocarbons; they have been adding to our energy consumption with no corresponding decline in hydrocarbon extraction. There is no “transition” occurring except the one that shows we are consuming more energy of various types. The hydrocarbon inheritance is not being replaced by a “cleaner” version since these technologies depend upon hydrocarbons for their existence, and they could be said to be exacerbating our predicament since they are enabling more consumption through their claims to be “clean and abundant”.
I see renewables, then, as another form of the technological salvation narrative that suggests that there’s no need to change our behaviours or policies. If only we build enough panels and turbines, then there’s no need to lose anything; we can continue to keep on keeping on. I hate to be the bearer of bad news, but the loss is fast approaching and we cannot avoid it. Renewables will not save us; they will simply allow us to pretend for a bit longer that the party needs not stop.
All this said, I will admit that renewables can indeed power a simpler, more localised, and less energy-intensive society. They can help provide light, communication, and basic services. But they are not a solution to powering Modernity and cannot replace hydrocarbons. They may help, marginally, mitigate our energy issue; but they are very expensive mitigation that comes with a steep cost in terms of further drawing down hydrocarbons and requiring ecologically-destructive industrial processes.
Physics is stubborn. Political opinions and ideology are meaningless to the laws of thermodynamics. And these laws are telling us in no uncertain terms and an increasingly louder voice that the era of relatively cheap, abundant, and concentrated energy is over. There’s no going back and trying it all again; we can only move forward into a world with a lot less.
This is not the only rule in the game we are playing, but it is the first one and the one that the rest all depend upon. It’s also the one that we’ve spent our inheritance on attempting to ignore.
We can’t ignore it any more.
What This Means
I am not suggesting that hydrocarbons will run out tomorrow, next week, or next year. That’s not the way this works. There remain huge reserves of these resources. The issue is not quantity but quality as demonstrated in the declining energy return on investment. The “easy” resources are gone and the “difficult” stuff remains with increasing costs in terms of money and energy to extract and refine it, leaving less surplus to maintain, let alone expand, societal complexities. This is the energy cliff many speak of, but it’s not a cliff one falls off suddenly but one that can be walked down one step at a time. The issue is that each step is getting steeper than the last.
Nor am I suggesting we should, or even can, stop using hydrocarbons immediately. We need hydrocarbons for all of our complex systems: food, healthcare, transportation–everything. Our societies would be thrown into utter chaos with mass starvation and the collapse of all of our institutional systems with a sudden loss of hydrocarbon energy. But what I would argue is that a transition away from hydrocarbons is inevitable and not a choice; it is a physical reality that will occur despite our wishes to the contrary. What remains to be seen is whether we can “manage” this transition in a manner that preserves something of our complexities or if the laws of thermodynamics impose it in a way that is sudden, violent, and chaotic.
I also am not suggesting that technology is merely a neutral tool in all this that can be used to build or destroy depending upon who is using it. As Erik Michaels argues, technology is more of a behaviour than a tool; an addiction as it were that has caused our ecological overshoot: “The predicament of ecological overshoot is caused by our behaviour,” he writes. “One isn’t going to change the dynamics of anything until one begins changing their behavior.” In this paradigmatic shift, he is suggesting that technology is not something we deploy responsibly or irresponsibly but that its use is the fundamental issue. Its use is exploitative in the sense that it consumes resources, grows the economy, and perpetuates overshoot. Even the “greenest” technology leads to further extraction and overshoot, so the question to ask is not whether a particular technology works but what is it working for? What is it “sustaining”? Who is it benefitting? This idea that some array of magical technologies will solve all our issues has become a religious belief; a salvation mythology that I will discuss in greater detail in a later chapter.
Here’s what I am saying: our grounded reality is best found in the laws of thermodynamics for they demonstrate the limits of what is possible. Humans, however, have constructed a civilisation that for the most part ignores these limits, treating them as if they are merely inconveniences to be dealt with via our ingenuity and technical prowess, or problems to be overcome by “free” markets and infinite substitutability. We’ve ignored these laws not because we’re unintelligent but because they’re mostly invisible to us. Entropy doesn’t knock on the door and present itself to us; nor does a declining EROI or shrinking surpluses. Instead, we notice the full shelves in the grocery store, the gadgets in our homes, the streaming sports game when we turn on the television. We see the abundance provided to us by cheap hydrocarbons and assume this is the natural order of things.
But this is not the natural order. It is an anomalous and very brief period in the 200,000+ year history of our species that has been possible because of a one-time cache of ancient sunlight that is nearing its end.
The first rule of the game is laid out through the laws of thermodynamics. Again, it’s not the only rule but it’s the one that makes all the rest possible and is the one that will bring them all down.
The Casino at Closing Time
Let’s return to the image I began this chapter with.
A casino sits in the desert. It has no name, sign, or doorman. The music is blaring while the lights shine brightly and the drinks are cheap. Everyone inside is winning.
The house doesn’t cheat, negotiate, or give extensions; it simply waits because the first rule of the game is that it always wins–in the end. All it has to do is wait for it knows every bet is but a loan, every win is temporary, and every hand eventually ends. Hopes, dreams, and plans for the future by the players are of no concern to the house; it only cares about the balance sheet of energy in and energy out, order and disorder, and profit and loss. The house is entropy itself and the game is the transformation of energy with every player sitting at the table whether they realise it or not.
Our species has been in the casino since we first arose and we have been winning for much of our existence. This has led us to believe our winning will go on forever, primarily because our ingenuity and technical innovativeness have allowed us to rig the game in our favour and beat the house. We’ve changed the game rules by overcoming the laws of thermodynamics and called it economic growth or technological progress.
The house, however, waits patiently in the background watching as the lights begin to dim and the kegs of beer start to run dry. And over the sound of the fading music is the sound of a gavel tapping on the hardened earth and growing ever louder.
Special Offer
If you have made it to the end of this Contemplation, I have an offer for you. Send me an email at olduvaitrilogy@gmail.com requesting a copy of Part 1 of my trilogy and I’ll fire off a PDF of it to you for your “fictional” reading pleasure. If you like the beginning of the tale, please consider ordering the trilogy here: Purchase Book(s) — Olduvai.ca.
What is going to be my standard WARNING/ADVICE going forward and that I have reiterated in various ways before this:
Only time will tell how this all unfolds but there’s nothing wrong with preparing for the worst by ‘collapsing now to avoid the rush’ and pursuing self-sufficiency. By this I mean removing as many dependencies on the Matrix as is possible and making do, locally. And if one can do this without negative impacts upon our fragile ecosystems or do so while creating more resilient ecosystems, all the better.
Building community (maybe even just household) resilience to as high a level as possible seems prudent given the uncertainties of an unpredictable future. There’s no guarantee it will ensure ‘recovery’ after a significant societal stressor/shock but it should increase the probability of it and that, perhaps, is all we can ‘hope’ for from its pursuit.
If you have arrived here and get something out of my writing, please consider ordering the trilogy of my “fictional” novel series, Olduvai (PDF files; only $9.99 Canadian), via my website or the link below — the “profits” of which help me to keep my internet presence alive and first book available in print (and is available via various online retailers).
Attempting a new payment system as I am contemplating shutting down my site in the future (given the ever-increasing costs to keep it running).
If you are interested in purchasing any of the 3 books individually or the trilogy, please try the link below indicating which book(s) you are purchasing.
Costs (Canadian dollars):
Book 1: $2.99
Book 2: $3.89
Book 3: $3.89
Trilogy: $9.99
Feel free to throw in a “tip” on top of the base cost if you wish; perhaps by paying in U.S. dollars instead of Canadian. Every few cents/dollars helps…
https://paypal.me/olduvaitrilogy?country.x=CA&locale.x=en_US
If you do not hear from me within 48 hours or you are having trouble with the system, please email me: olduvaitrilogy@gmail.com.
You can also find a variety of resources, particularly my summary notes for a handful of texts, especially William Catton’s Overshoot and Joseph Tainter’s Collapse of Complex Societies: see here.