Home » Economics » Today’s Contemplation: Collapse Cometh CCLXVIII–The Representative Racket: A Canadian Reflection on a Historical Artifact

Today’s Contemplation: Collapse Cometh CCLXVIII–The Representative Racket: A Canadian Reflection on a Historical Artifact

Today’s Contemplation: Collapse Cometh CCLXVIII–
The Representative Racket: A Canadian Reflection on a Historical Artifact

More and more I’m coming to the conclusion that “representative” (or “indirect”) democracy is just another in a long line of ruling elite rackets. And by “racket” I’m thinking of Major General Smedley Butler’s definition used in War is a Racket: “A racket is best described, I believe, as something that is not what it seems to the majority of people. Only a small ‘inside’ group knows what it is about. It is conducted for the benefit of the very few, at the expense of the very many.”

historyonthenet.com

I should be clear here that Butler’s definition implies conscious coordination among an inside group, which is entirely possible within the sociopolitical realm to which I am applying it, but much of what I will lay out is more of a structural racket as opposed to a conspiratorial one. A system that operates through incentives, career pathways, and professional alignments don’t require secret meetings to reach the same endgame: a small group benefits at the expense of the many and the system’s operation appears opaque and problematic to those it disadvantages. Regardless, the definition’s core piece holds: something not what it seems is conducted for the few at the expense of the many. And the system can be abused by some and using the system in ways that make it appear very conspiratorial.

The mainstream narrative regarding democracy goes something like this for the average citizen: “My vote gives me agency in the policies and actions carried out as well as the leadership in my town/municipality, province/state, and nation.” This belief quite frankly is bunk, especially in the Canadian system where the Prime Minister is chosen by a select few party members and a Member of Parliament (MP) represents thousands of voters, where a provincial Premier can hold a majority legislature with less than 40% of the popular vote, and where a municipal council can be elected by a third of eligible voters and their decisions overruled by the provincial government at will.

I’ve reached my conclusion not simply through reading or observation but molded by years of direct experience. I’ve had direct interactions with elected representatives at various levels (municipal and provincial), with unelected bureaucratic gatekeepers at every level, and with government machinery that markets itself as serving the public but seems to operate according to its own imperatives. Virtually every experience I’ve had has reinforced the same lesson: government is not an institution that serves the interests of the masses, despite how it markets itself to the voting citizenry; it serves its own perpetuation and the interests of those few well-connected interest groups and individuals.

Let me put this more plainly since the rest of what I argue in this Contemplation rests on it: sociopolitical systems have evolved into institutions that primarily serve a ruling elite whose main interest is to maintain control over the wealth-generation and extraction systems that support their power and prestige. While some collective goods do flow to society in general, they tend to be the “price to pay” to help prevent mass revolt and preserve status quo arrangements–they are not evidence of benevolent governance. This is offered as a hypothesis consistent with the evidence as opposed to a proven fact. The burden of proof should rest with those who claim benevolence and given that the patterns of concession are granted only under pressure suggest it is a system that primarily serves the ruling elite.

Consider this all in terms of our ruling elite’s pursuit of the perpetual growth chalice. Virtually all of their wealth and power depends on this pursuit, and it will therefore be pursued regardless of any negative consequences. And when biogeophysical limits begin to force its contraction (as it has been doing), the elite feign ignorance, deny limits exist, criminalise dissent, find scapegoats to blame, increase their extractive mechanisms, intensify supportive ideologies, and employ various financial and monetary machinations to paper it over so that the status quo systems can continue for those it most benefits. They protect their share by any and all means available to them. The population outside of this elite group matters only as taxpayers and labourers, and ecological destruction matters only so far as it doesn’t threaten profits.

The generally held belief that governing institutions serve the masses in some beneficent manner is a myth; a myth propagated and reinforced to help ensure consent. It’s important to understand this as it helps to reframe how and why these institutions originated, are maintained, and what their motivations are. And they are, in this reframing, diametrically opposed to the image they portray themselves as. The current operating principles of government are not to serve the people but to help maintain elite power and wealth; a set of principles that are likely to intensify as the systems that sustain them begin to contract and crack.

If you’re new to my writing, check out this overview.

See my free book offer to readers at the end of this Contemplation…

CLICK HERE

NOTE: I may be taking a longish break from posting these regular Contemplations as I have begun working on a much longer writing project that I am tentatively calling “A Users Manual For the End of the World As We Know It”. Stay tuned…

History of Representative Democracy: An Elite Invention from the Start
History is fairly clear that our governing institutions did not evolve as a mechanism for popular self-rule and have simply become corrupted over time. That is not what has brought us under the cloak of the present-day racket. The form of social organisation that has evolved to dominate our species (i.e., the state) formed alongside agriculture, surplus, and class division with its earliest function to collect taxes, conscript labour, wage war, and enforce the property claims of those with accumulated wealth. In other words, they arose as instruments of elite rule. The monumental construction that accompanied this history (e.g., the temples, palaces, citadels) were not democratic assembly halls but the headquarters of the ruling elite.

Representative democracy’s history is not a steady and progressive evolution towards popular sovereignty but a shifting series of adaptations to changing circumstances by the ruling elite. The assembly of citizens (ekklesia) in Athens did not “represent” all the citizens; women, slaves, and “free” resident aliens were completely excluded. The Roman Republic, which fancied itself as a model of mixed government, was in actuality an oligarchy where the Senate represented patrician class interests and the comitia centuriata consistently voted in favour of the wealthy. Parliaments of medieval Europe were convened by monarchs wishing to extract revenue from fellow elites (i.e., nobles, clergy; who in turn extracted from the masses) with little to no concern for the population at large, except as labourers and soldiers.

The direct ancestor of my Canadian parliament is the English version that originated as a gathering of ruling elite (i.e., barons and bishops) by the English king to give their consent to taxation. The House of Commons arose as a franchise restricted to male property owners, and remained so for centuries. It was not a chamber of the people, unless they owned property and could afford to send representatives, but a gathering of those with interests the Crown sought to manage. In Canada, it wasn’t until the 20th century that women won voting rights, and until the 1960s some Indigenous peoples were excluded.

Who were the Canadian “Fathers of Confederation”? Male lawyers, businessmen, and railway profiteers seeking a strong central institution to promote westward expansion and facilitate commerce. They feared democracy’s “excesses” just as their American counterparts did. Canada’s first Prime Minister, Sir John A. Macdonald, was clear and concise about his desire for a strong executive and appointed-for-life Senate (whose members were arguably patronage appointments and partisan hacks). And the foundational act that created the Dominion of Canada–British North American Act–was a business plan for a nation state and certainly not a charter of freedoms for citizens.

This history gets to the heart of my Contemplation: our “representative” institutions were designed to manage society on behalf of a few, not to empower the many. While the forms these institutions have taken have changed over the years (i.e., the franchise has expanded by allowing more citizens to vote) the fundamental architecture remains solidly the same: the state is an instrument of the ruling elite. Our current iteration may be the most sophisticated yet with its appearance of popular consent, but it is still a device for legitimising the rule of the elite.

As the late comedian George Carlin opined: “It’s a big club, and you ain’t in it.”

Comparison to Direct Democracy
Here I want to review a slight twist on the representative form most common across the planet, that of “Direct Democracy”. As practised in history (Athenian city-states) or currently (Swiss cantons), this messy and time-consuming approach that demands a difficult-to-sustain level of civic engagement requires active citizen participation in the decision-making process as opposed to the off-loading of such responsibility to another. Note that I am not idealising direct democracy here for it too can be captured by money, the tyranny of the majority, and influence of the elite as some evidence around some referendum campaigns have shown. I’m not attempting to show that it is a perfect replacement for the representative form but it does help to remove some of the layers of alienation and insulation that make political capture easier and accountability nearly impossible.

Representative democracy outsources citizen decision-making and responsibility to a municipal councillor or member of provincial or federal parliament, resulting in the masses becoming spectators in their own governance. To say this creates a significant psychological and practical disconnect would be an understatement. The Canadian system (derived from the English Westminster model) adds additional layers of alienation that other nations–who vote directly for their national leader–don’t contain. Canadians don’t vote for the person who holds the most power in their country, the Prime Minister. Canadians vote for a local member of parliament and the party with the most seats form the national government, the Prime Minister being the leader of the winning party (and who has been chosen by party members)–and with the first-past-the-post system, it’s even more non-representative than intimated in this description.

Even more disconcerting is that once in power, the Office of the Prime Minister (PMO) exerts iron control over the caucus–through the party whip–with MPs expected to toe the party line regardless of constituent wishes, and those who don’t are punished. Such a system makes a mockery of the concept of “local representation”; it is a complete fiction. MPs do not give voice to citizens; they give voice to Ottawa in their riding. They are obedient cogs in the governing machine and not independent representatives of their riding and its constituents.

Direct democracy works quite differently in that if I want to see a policy or action taken or halted, I have to persuade my neighbours rather than attempt to persuade a professional politician whose incentives are likely quite different from mine and is far more susceptible to the lobbying efforts of interested and invested others. I have no party leadership aspirations, campaign donors, lobbyists, or media to answer to or be incentivised by.

Given all of the above it seems rather self-evident that the political game is rigged from the outset, and not in favour of the general citizenry. It is heavily skewed in favour of a ruling elite whose interests are significantly different from the “average” citizen.

The Racket Aspect: Federal Level
This brings me back to Smedley Butler and his description of a racket. This representative system most nation states have in place is the perfect governing racket. It certainly is not what it seems to most. While on the surface it is perceived as one of popular sovereignty where leaders are chosen by the people of a nation, it is in actuality a system that makes choices in a pre-selected manner by a narrow elite. Further, the party system in place ensures debate and opinion is quite narrowly allowed and never threatens the fundamental interests of the donor class.

The system works to benefit the very few: the politicians, the corporate interests that fund campaigns, the lobbyists that compose the legislation, and the financial institutions that profit from the policies rolled out. The masses, on the other hand, get the bill for all this while their wages stagnate, public services decay, and their environment is poisoned and degraded; and all the while they are told that they are the sovereign rulers making the ultimate decisions through the ballot box.

Let me expand on the concentration of power in the Canadian Prime Minister’s Office here. The federal government’s own guide on cabinet formation lays out the evidence. The appointment of ministers, creation of new portfolios, and even cabinet expansion via “Ministers of State” (whose salaries fall outside the official Salaries Act) are all within the purview of the Office with the ability of “considerable latitude” as the guideline points out. There’s “no legal standing” as a position for the Deputy Prime Minister; their power is entirely derived from the personal delegation of the Prime Minister. What does this all mean? It means that a party leader–chosen by party members, not the citizens–who could form the government with less than 40% of the popular vote, holds near-monarchical authority over the entire executive branch of government.

Then there’s the Senate: an unelected and unaccountable chamber of patronage appointees who can, in theory, block legislation passed by the elected House. This relic of a bygone era serves no democratic purpose other than to feign a check on executive branch authority. Canada’s present Prime Minister, Mark Carney–an economist by trade who headed two nations’ central banks–suspended operations of the Independent Advisory Board for Senate Appointments, shortly after gaining his position, and threw out the “non-partisan” appointment standards to appoint his own principal secretary and a sitting Conservative MP. One of the opposition parties–New Democratic Party (NDP)–responded to this move stating “The Senate is an archaic institution that violates the basic principles of democratic government. The fact that a Prime Minister can appoint legislators who are accountable to no voters, often for decades, and who possess powers similar to the House of Commons, is indefensible in a modern democracy.” Moreover, recent polling shows a majority of Canadians believe the Senate should be significantly reformed: either abolished or members elected.

Then there’s floor-crossing, that occasional phenomenon of MPs joining another party after an election. In 2026, and within five months of an election, five opposition MPs crossed to join Mark Carney’s Liberal party to help it form a majority government. NDP MP and leader Don Davies soon thereafter introduced Bill C-278, a floor-crossing bill that would require such members to face a by-election given voters cast their ballot for a candidate representing a particular party and then suddenly, without accountability or recall, their “representative” candidate switched parties. As the NDP leader stated: “If you want to change parties, fine. You resign, you run in a by-election under your new party.” This is Davies’s fifth attempt since 2008 to get such legislation implemented. As a Private Member’s Bill, Davies sits at number 236 in the current draw, making its passage virtually impossible–let alone even considered and debated. That a bill that would enhance democratic accountability is buried while legislation supporting corporate interests is elevated in consideration is quite telling of the system’s priorities.

Finally, there’s the often criticised First Past the Post (FPTP) electoral system. Even a 2016 special committee of the House of Commons called the system “unrepresentative and unfair”, yet it remains firmly entrenched. Basically, the system allows a party to win a majority of seats with less than 40% of the vote. It is characterised by strategic voting and vote-splitting, and where regional divisions get systematically amplified. As a petition to the House to have it discarded argued: “FPTP produces results that do not reflect the will of voters, contributing to polarisation, voter cynicism, and declining trust in government.” And as often happens, campaign promises to revise the system and reflect a more “representative” one fade from view once a party gets into government.

The Racket Aspect: Provincial Level
While composed of its own distinct mechanisms, the provincial level of Canadian government is no better and reveals its own racket logic. For example, under Section 92(8) of the Constitution Act, 1867, provincial governments hold exclusive jurisdiction over the level of government most directly relevant to citizen’s daily lives–municipalities–that exists legally at the whim of the province; its powers and boundaries are strictly determined and controlled by provincial legislatures.

This situation makes the legal status of municipalities fragile and contingent at best. According to an Ontario Legislative Research Service report, municipal structures are arbitrarily shaped by provinces with a mix of “single-tier” and “two-tier” systems. Such arbitrariness was evident in the 1990s when by provincial diktat, a number of major cities were reconfigured with imposed amalgamations of communities. In Manitoba, this has been reflected in the mismatch of the ability to provide services depending on municipality size, with only one city (Winnipeg) being provided additional powers and all others governed by a general Municipal Act where smaller communities (under 750) are required to provide fewer services regardless of needs. A similar situation occurs in Nova Scotia, where only Halifax sits outside provincial diktats. Quebec demonstrates perhaps the most complex system, a two-tier structure where municipalities are organised into “regional county municipalities” with provincial laws slicing power and responsibility across levels. Quebec is not unique in this regard but does show the most complex organisation with distinct composition and powers.

What a municipality can and cannot do on behalf of its residents is strictly dependent upon a provincial government’s granting, or denial, of power. The collective will of citizens is mostly irrelevant in such a system. But it’s even worse than that described above.

The “notwithstanding clause” (section 33 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms) allows higher levels of government–federal and provincial–to override protections in specific rights areas for a prescribed period of time, five years. So, even if the Charter guarantees certain rights, a provincial or federal government can suspend them “temporarily” via legislative action. Municipal governments are not granted this ability, but provincial governments can use it as a tool to intervene in local affairs if so desired.

The Racket Aspect: Municipal Level
Theoretically, municipal governments are the level most closely relevant to the daily lives of a nation’s citizens. It is responsible for such mundane aspects as garbage collection, public transit, road maintenance, local planning, and water procurement.

Despite this, polling data shows that voter participation collapses at this level. A recent poll of Montreal municipal voters found that 86% reported they believed voting was a civic “duty”, regardless of the level in question. However, 93% claimed to have voted federally, 89% provincially, and only 41% at the municipal level. It wasn’t that citizens didn’t value the principles of democracies, according to the researchers, it was that municipalities encountered structural difficulties in mobilising voters. Given that non-voters cited ineligibility and practical obstacles as their reasons for not participating rather than a lack of interest, it appears the collapse in participation is structural and not due to apathy.

Even more striking data comes out of Halifax where a 2024 municipal election showed only about a third of eligible voters participated, but 73% voted federally and 45% provincially. This pattern–where voters seem more motivated to participate where broader national issues are concerned but less so the more the issues are day-to-day–is repeated in most regions of Canada.

Perhaps this is not an accidental collapse in participation; perhaps it is a structural product of the “representative” democracy occurring at the municipal level. There are no formal party labels. The media coverage is much sparser. Low-profile candidates are the norm. Limited campaign funding supports it.

The Montreal survey suggested the reasons for non-voting municipally included ineligibility and practical obstacles, but not a lack of interest. What seems to be behind this pattern is more of a perceptual phenomenon: votes don’t really matter municipally since council decisions are constrained significantly by provincial regulations and constraints–so why vote in such elections? The entire belief in “representation” is put to the test at the municipal level; and is found wanting for most.

My Own Experience: The Racket Up Close
My beliefs about the racket nature of government are not some theoretical one, although my understanding of the historical roots of governing institutions certainly plays a part. It is the result of my own interactions with government at every level, with elected officials, and with unelected bureaucrats for more than four decades. It is the logical conclusion I’ve reached after repeated confirmation that the system is designed to manage, process, deflect, and ultimately exhaust us into compliance. Keep in mind that the following are anecdotes and not systemic evidence, although I would hazard a guess that the pattern they illustrate will be recognised by any who have tried to engage with government.

Some may recognise the pattern. You contact an elected “representative” with a concern and receive an email/form letter back thanking you for your correspondence and highlighting that your issue has been “noted”. Oftentimes the content of the reply has zero to do with the issue raised; it’s mostly regurgitated talking points about what a great job your elected representative or his/her party is doing for you and your community. Nothing changes, so you follow up and/or escalate, perhaps getting referred to a bureaucrat. The unelected bureaucrat explains that the matter falls under another’s jurisdiction, or that the policy is set somewhere else, or that the operational policy to address the issue does not allow for such, or that the timeline to change such policy was years ago or not for a few more years so is far beyond their control. You are passed along a chain of offices or people who are each insulated from responsibility or accountability, and whose function appears to be to ensure that the institution is not disturbed by the public that it claims to serve. Please move along, there is nothing to see here.

It’s particularly revealing what the unelected bureaucrat tells us about the system and their role in it. They appear to hold much of the power–the power to interpret regulations, approve or deny permits, set timelines, determine outcomes–but are accountable to no voter or resident. Their accountability, should any exist, is to their superiors and the institution. While the public is marketed as the ultimate concern, in reality they tend to be perceived as an inconvenience, a case file whose transaction needs to be managed; not a relationship to be honoured.

This is where the visibility of the racket becomes most apparent. The unelected bureaucrats–who work on the public dime–tend to work with and for the invested groups such as developers, consultants, and other well-connected private interests, and often in opposition to the citizenry’s wants and needs for whom they are supposed to be serving. The citizen is met with jurisdictional buck-passing and procedural walls while the developer who wants rezoning amendments or “minor” variances is guided through the process and accommodated. The developer has relationships, a file that is actively managed, pre-application meetings, sharing of drafts, technical guidance, and internal advocacy; and all before the public even has a hint as to the proposed project. The citizen, on the other hand, learns of the completed application proposal after the deal is all but done, provided a narrow comment window, and is usually informed that since all the boxes have been checked there is nothing that can stop the development. This is not a neutral bureaucracy but an active participant in the racket who is facilitating the interests of those who are generating growth, tax revenue, and political donations. It is also the one managing–and usually dismissing–the concerns of community members. It is in name only that the bureaucrats are “public” servants for in practice they are servants to the growth machine and the well-connected interests that feed it. Bureaucrats aren’t necessarily corrupt and developers aren’t necessarily villains (although some may well be in both cases), there simply exist structural incentives that lead to the two becoming aligned with citizens left without the advocacy that developers appear to receive from bureaucrats. This conclusion is warranted given the consistency of the pattern laid out above.

While there may exist corruption and bad faith in all of this, it is mostly structural and built into the system. Government staff of municipal planners, engineers, consultants, and economic development officers are all trained and educated in disciplines that view growth, development, and expansion as self-evidently good for all. They are all tightly linked to the development industry through their professional associations, peer networks, career trajectories, and future employment prospects. These are not disinterested public servants. They are all part of a growth coalition that spans both public and private sectors. Paid directly or indirectly by the taxpayers whose interests they often betray.

I am highlighting here a stark and deliberate asymmetry: the “expansionists” are paid to attend to the project. They have staff, budgets, and the time to do this. The average citizen, on the other hand, must mount any opposition in the margins of a full and busy life. The balance that governing institutions should be bringing to the table is nowhere to be seen. Oversight of the growth machine falls upon the citizenry almost exclusively and on a voluntary basis. The developer’s representatives are paid to be present and active in pushing the project through. The resident who is concerned about the community impacts and ecological consequences is not. The bureaucrat has full-time employment and a nice pension upon retirement so long as the growth machine keeps bulldozing its way forward. The citizen has only what spare time they can find and diminishing faith that their efforts matter. The system is heavily rigged in favour of the expansionists by a system that pays professionals to advocate for growth and ensure it gets done while the ones most impacted are left scrambling to find time and the energy to act in response.

Elected “representatives” are rarely better at serving the electorate. They tend to be focussed upon legitimising their positions–and/or the next election–through a constant barrage of assertions as to the great things they’re doing for the municipality/province/nation. A constituent who contacts their office becomes a data point, a problem to be managed (typically by someone else), a potential vote. Even those few with the best of intentions may try to help but they are significantly constrained in what they can do and tend to be incentivised to prioritise the party or institutional line over public interest. The worst of them ignore constituents entirely–this is the experience of myself and most of my neighbours with respect to our local ward councillor for the past decade.

Then there is the sheer impenetrability of the various systems. Government language is purposely designed not to clarify but to obscure. Processes are not meant to empower but to exhaust. Attempts to engage in good faith are met with a wall of jargon, procedure, and jurisdictional buck-passing that sends a clear message: this is not the “representation” you thought you had; this government is ours, not yours, and your role is to pay taxes, obey laws, and legitimise the system through periodic vote-casting.

I have many personal examples from over the years. What follows are just some relatively recent ones.

One was my being bounced back and forth from my town to my region (at least a dozen back and forth communications with as many people) regarding responsibility for dead and dying trees along our fenceline but on regional property that needed felling before they came down on the adjacent road–one had already come down to some extent on both the road and one of my greenhouses during an ice storm–that took well over a decade to get resolved. And if I hadn’t been present when workers arrived to take care of the trees, the result would have been a single tree removed rather than the seven most needed to be, had finally been agreed to, and had been marked for removal. That there’s still more to be removed is my next decade-long adventure in banging my head against a brick wall.

Then there was trying to get stop signs installed at the corner where our house is situated to help slow drivers down at a problematic intersection in a very hilly area where school bus stops are located and turning vehicles take their chances every time they are there. It was prompted by a near-miss with a student being picked up by a school bus that I witnessed. Another almost two-decade long tale where the reasons given for not making the intersection a three-way stop were finally and miraculously irrelevant when the region decided to put a number of all-way stops in along the road in question to help slow traffic after a full community meeting to address speeding and dangerous conditions for cyclists and pedestrians got heated–no, I was not present as I’ve lost all appetite for the theatre that such “consultations” are.

But perhaps the most troubling example–and the one that most clearly illustrates the bureaucracy working hand-in-glove with developer interests against the citizenry–was the coercive and nefarious manner in which our entire community was forced to cap perfectly functioning wells and pay to be hooked up to municipally-provided water. We were fed a completely fabricated narrative of imminent health and safety issues because of a supposed polluted aquifer along with concern for our kettle lake, exposed to a rigged plebiscite where non-votes were counted in favour of the project, experienced years of no real residential expansion due to water system limits of the municipal system installed but are now experiencing a ballooning of residential and commercial development–that virtually no residents want–because, miraculously, using wells to allow such expansion is fine and dandy. The institution and its bureaucrats who told us our wells were unsafe are now informing us that new development is possible with private wells. The institution that justified the capping of private wells and hook up to municipal water at the citizens’ expense is the same one profitting from new expansion without the constraints of a maxed-out municipal water system.

And, of course, no one is taking responsibility for any of this with much gaslighting regarding what occurred in the past. And I won’t even get into the faulty framing of the need for massive residential housing expansion due to a “housing crisis” caused by insufficient supply–when it’s in actuality an “affordability crisis” caused by institutional policies (e.g., massive debt/credit creation and low interest rates) and the commodification of housing as a financial asset of the elite. The bureaucracy, developers, consultants, and politicians are reading from the same growth playbook and the citizens who object are treated as obstacles to be managed and assuaged rather than residents to be served; and whose opposition must be organised in their spare time between work and family while the expansionists are paid–by the citizenry–to be there.

I could go on, but I think I’ve made my point: the system doesn’t care one iota about the citizens it’s supposed to “represent”. And I admit that these are minor annoyances in the grand scheme of things and my attempts to derail the perpetual growth agenda, where I’ve truly run into a brick wall. Although, I will admit that the water situation continues to infuriate me 25 years after the fact, particularly with the expansion of buildings being allowed with the admission that well water is fine.

How This Form of Democracy Exacerbates Our Collapse/Overshoot Predicament
The biophysical issues that beset Modernity (e.g., biodiversity loss, resource depletion, ocean acidification, novel entity spread, etc.) are the consequences of ecological overshoot. Humanity should be responding to these in immediate, decisive, and systemic ways with a collective recognition of limits and a willingness to make profound sacrifices for long-term benefits. Such a response, however, is structurally impossible given our parliamentary system and its short election cycles and subservience to corporate capital.

Short-term thinking predominates the landscape. Not as a bug but as a feature of the sociopolitical and economic systems in place. Even if they are aware, politicians dare not tell the public the hard truths around overshoot and collapse with their penchant for re-election always close at hand. Prescribing a contraction of the economy and/or reduction in consumption would do little to help their political careers. The promise of more economic growth, jobs, and consumption is the standard fare, but these pathways are the very cause of our predicaments and accelerate our journey over the cliff edge.

And keep in mind that the unelected and unaccountable bureaucracy is complicit and facilitating this acceleration. Our governing institutions and its workforce is structurally aligned with the growth imperative. The approval of more development, construction, and expansion feeds the performance metrics, budgets, and professional incentives of the bureaucracy. Even should a public servant wish to say no to a project on ecological grounds, institutional pressure leads to approval by “making it work”. Developers are not adversaries but partners, and the citizen who objects is not a stakeholder to be heard but a nuisance to be managed. So, overshoot is administered through the day-to-day operations of a bureaucracy that has internalised the growth imperative, views it as their reason for being, and is paid very much not to understand the consequences of its decisions and actions. The citizen who does understand and is very much concerned about the pursuit of the perpetual growth chalice is left banging their head against the wall of an institution built to manage their “hysteria”.

The record of my nation state in this regard is something to behold. For example, Canada is one of the world’s largest emitters of greenhouse gases, and on a per capita basis leaves most other nations far behind in its dust. Canada is a petro-state whose economy is greatly dependent upon the extraction and export of hydrocarbons–particularly the most ecologically destructive form in its Athabasca Oil Sands. All of Canada’s political parties have embraced this model of perpetual growth, even the so-called Greens who argue for expansion based upon “clean” technologies and “sustainable” industries. And regardless of the party in power, hydrocarbon extraction continues to grow and be subsidised; all while making pronouncements and promises of “sustainability” and “environmental benefits”. The contradictions abound and are never resolved. The marketing simply becomes more intense, just as the racket requires.

But it’s worse, for the racket helps to fuel the tribalism that prevents the nation from addressing the crisis. Left versus right. East versus west. Urban versus rural. Alberta, home of the oil sands, recently held a province-wide referendum regarding whether to pursue separation or not. Remaining with Canada won by a wide margin (approximately 77% to 23%) but this is not to suggest the movement is over. Some may argue that this example contradicts my racket thesis, but it does not. The referendum outcome was not really ever in doubt so its occurrence was more to help maintain legitimacy than anything else. But even this failed movement served the interests of those wishing to gain access to Alberta’s oil and gas reserves as evidenced by the public support given to the leaders of the separatist movement by U.S. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent and Elon Musk–funding supposedly came from U.S. interests as well. While this first attempt at separation failed, the idea that the federal government does not “represent” the interests of its provinces is growing across the nation.

Regardless of these growing divides, the ruling party of Canada always agrees on the path of pursuing endless growth and resource extraction. The house is burning down and Canadians are fighting each other over the scraps that lay about. Our “representative” system of government unfortunately channels our discontent into an us and them paradigm that completely ignores the biophysical realities and limits we face. For lack of a more accurate term, this death cult we are part of is masquerading as a democracy and convincing us we are its leaders. After all, isn’t this what the voters want?

The power inherent in the PMO makes all of this worse given that it allows a single individual whose party was elected by a small percentage of the population to ram through pipelines, approve arms deals, and commit the country to war with minimal to no parliamentary oversight. The PMO is an unelected and unaccountable centre of power that operates with imperial pretensions that could be argued to be not a democratic institution but that of a dictatorship.

With the same dynamic in play, Canada’s provincial governments are no better. A provincial premier who has been elected with less than 40% of the vote can impose all kinds of policies upon municipalities at will. From amalgamations to the overriding of municipal decisions, distant provincial capitals have exclusive jurisdiction over towns and cities. This is, for all intents and purposes, centralised control cloaked in a shield of “democracy”.

The collapse of voter participation at the municipal level may well be the ultimate indictment of this obvious charade. A system that is responsible for the daily affairs of most people has lost all legitimacy when only a third of its population casts a ballot. The psychological toll of the ongoing “representative” racket seems most visible in this statistic. Real decisions are made elsewhere so why bother voting in local elections is the internalised lesson: the province, federal government, corporations, and global capital are the ultimate arbiters of policy.

Where To?
So where does a population, be it a local community or that of a nation state, go from this difficult position where abandoning the fantasy of representative democracy is an admission that there’s no formal, institutional path to change?

Perhaps the first step is to abandon the delusion that our governing institutions can help lead a needed change. Change is not going to come from them or the ballot box since the individuals, parties, and institutions are all compromised in the sense that they are designed to absorb and neutralise dissent. Experience has taught me, better than any book could, that engaging in good faith with a rigged system is pointless.

Next, as an antidote to the representative racket we should focus on where some agency might actually be possible: locally. Direct democracy at a local municipal level may not address in any meaningful way the predicaments we face, but it might help to get the ball rolling in terms of building structures of mutual aid, food sovereignty, and local resilience. It may be possible to create real and face-to-face networks not mediated by distant politicians through its mechanism of increased community involvement. It may be the only way to reclaim some of the agency in our lives and prepare for the coming storm. This should not be considered a retreat from politics but a relocation of it to something where humans can actually know each other, deliberate together, and hold each other accountable.

Localism is not the only possible response to my diagnosis. Fleeing. Mass civil disobedience. Preparation for conflict. These are possible responses as well. Our sociopolitical institutions, however, are designed for dissent; they can absorb most of it. And certainly the ballot box offers no chance at altering the trajectory. I truly believe that the most likely response that will preserve some agency and some community support while the larger system collapses is through the creation of local alternatives. It’s a choice and not a logical necessity but I do believe it’s the option with the most consistent values in light of my analysis.

Perhaps we also need to begin living as we want to in the future by creating institutions of self- and local-governance. Create seed banks, tool libraries, and local currencies. Bring neighbours together to discuss issues of importance to the community. Build from the ground up a movement that focuses energies where it is most important: the local community.

And while this may be moot in the long run, perhaps part of the local work should involve watching the institutional bureaucracy closely, attending council meetings, demanding transparency on meetings and negotiations with developers, requesting public records, and making it costly for the system to serve private interests over public ones. The system is not going to be reformed from the inside, but maybe its operations can be made more visible and contested at the local level where some small impact may occur. The asymmetry I’ve described is no accident. It’s a structural feature of the racket. Ways need to be found and implemented for counterbalancing the paid advocates of growth, and the best chance for these may be at the local level where some agency may still exist.

And finally, it might be worthwhile to continue to speak up and engage in a conversation that helps to delegitimise the racket. Don’t participate in the rituals of consent. Performative voting. Partisan cheerleading. Worship of “leaders”. Be loyal to your community and land, not a party or nation state.

The racket that is representative democracy is not going to be voted out of existence. There is no path towards local resilience and self-sufficiency via the ballot box. The current governing system is more likely to collapse under its own contradictions and as such there’s no point in attempting to save it. Instead we need to build lifeboats of local communities and a new way of organising them for when sociopolitical collapse finally arrives, as it surely will.

The Deeper Historical Truth
I hope that the above analysis shows not that our governing systems have simply fallen short of the democratic ideals most believe in, but that the systems were never designed to achieve them in the first place. From the Roman Senate to the Canadian Parliament, governing institutions were created by the elites for the elites as instruments to manage populations, extract revenue, wage war, and secure property. The adaptations that have evolved over the centuries have not been a gift to the citizenry to give them a voice; they are minor concessions granted as new mechanisms of elite control grew.

Representative democracy is a culmination of centuries of elite rule and power. It is the most sophisticated tool yet for convincing the masses that they have agency in their societies. The legitimisation activities of elections, debates, and consultations are the sugar to make the medicine of elite rule taste sweeter. The racket that it is is no deviation from the historical norm of elite power and rule; it is simply dressed up differently than that of millennia past with the idea of popular sovereignty.

My personal experiences have made all of this undeniable in my mind. I’ve interacted with governing institutions that are not neutral arbiters attempting to weave an impartial path between competing interests. They support their own interests, culture, and imperatives, and mostly represent the ruling elite and their goals. They are staffed by those who have internalised this pathway and consider the public a nuisance. They are represented by those who view the public as potential votes and tools of legitimisation, little more.

The system is not broken; it is working exactly as designed. The masses are kept at arm’s length with their concerns processed but without actually addressing them. This is what preserves the institutions from actual citizen participation.

So, I am not attempting to fix a broken democracy. If anything, I have been advocating for some genuine self-governance and such a system cannot begin within our current institutions since they have been and continue to be by, for, and of a ruling elite and will do all in their power to prevent direct citizen input and direction. Mutual aid and solidarity will only be possible through its creation with neighbours, not through a historical artifact of elite rule. And creating local systems before the inevitable collapse of our current sociopolitical ones should be one of the goals of local communities, with the recognition that we have outgrown the historical artifact of elite rule.


Special Offer

If you have made it to the end of this Contemplation, I have an offer for you. Send me an email at olduvaitrilogy@gmail.com requesting a copy of Part 1 of my trilogy and I’ll fire off a PDF of it to you for your “fictional” reading pleasure. If you like the beginning of the tale, please consider ordering the trilogy here: Purchase Book(s) — Olduvai.ca.


Only time will tell how this all unfolds but there’s nothing wrong with preparing for the worst by ‘collapsing now to avoid the rush’ and pursuing self-sufficiency. By this I mean removing as many dependencies on the Matrix as is possible and making do, locally. And if one can do this without negative impacts upon our fragile ecosystems or do so while creating more resilient ecosystems, all the better.

Building community (maybe even just household) resilience to as high a level as possible seems prudent given the uncertainties of an unpredictable future. There’s no guarantee it will ensure ‘recovery’ after a significant societal stressor/shock but it should increase the probability of it and that, perhaps, is all we can ‘hope’ for from its pursuit.


If you have arrived here and get something out of my writing, please consider ordering the trilogy of my “fictional” novel series, Olduvai (PDF files; only $9.99 Canadian), via my website or the link below — the “profits” of which help me to keep my internet presence alive and first book available in print (and is available via various online retailers).

Attempting a new payment system as I am contemplating shutting down my site in the future (given the ever-increasing costs to keep it running).

If you are interested in purchasing any of the 3 books individually or the trilogy, please try the link below indicating which book(s) you are purchasing.

Costs (Canadian dollars):
Book 1: $2.99
Book 2: $3.89
Book 3: $3.89
Trilogy: $9.99

Feel free to throw in a “tip” on top of the base cost if you wish; perhaps by paying in U.S. dollars instead of Canadian. Every few cents/dollars helps…

https://paypal.me/olduvaitrilogy?country.x=CA&locale.x=en_US

If you do not hear from me within 48 hours or you are having trouble with the system, please email me: olduvaitrilogy@gmail.com.

You can also find a variety of resources, particularly my summary notes for a handful of texts, especially William Catton’s Overshoot and Joseph Tainter’s Collapse of Complex Societies: see here.